Owner’s Audit reachme@amirsani.com

Operator selection and review from the owner’s side

Hotel management companies in Europe: how owners evaluate them

Every management company presents well. The properties they already run are the only evidence that is not a presentation.

A hotel management company runs a hotel on the owner’s behalf under a management agreement, for base and incentive fees. Owners evaluating operators in Europe compare fee structures, brand strength, distribution, and references. What they cannot get from a pitch is how the operator performs for a guest who is not expected. The Owner’s Audit supplies it: an unannounced stay at the properties the operator already runs, with the digital estate that produces their demand reviewed beforehand, reported to the owner before the agreement is signed or renewed.

What owners usually compare

  • Fees and terms. Base fee, incentive fee, term, performance test thresholds, cure rights, termination on sale.
  • Brand and distribution. Loyalty programme contribution, direct booking share, the cost of the channels the brand brings.
  • Track record. Portfolio performance, comparable assets, references from other owners.
  • People. The general manager the operator proposes, and how long the last three lasted.

What a pitch cannot show

How the operator’s properties surface in search, answer engines and generative search. Whether their Instagram creates demand or documents the property. How their booking path converts. What a guest receives at arrival, in the room, at dinner, on the course, in the spa, in the kids’ club. What happens when that guest raises a problem. These are the things the owner is actually buying, and none of them are in the deck.

Testing an operator before signing

  1. Choose two or three of the operator’s existing properties closest in type to the owner’s asset: luxury family, golf, five-star resort.
  2. Review their digital estates. Search, social, activation, demand capture, the technical booking path.
  3. Stay, unannounced, as a paying guest. A minimum of four nights, with shortcomings raised so recovery is observed. At an operator’s own properties the posture is unannounced but not silent; at a competitor’s it is fully silent.
  4. Report. What the operator delivers when no one is watching, and what that implies for the agreement being negotiated.

Reviewing the operator you already have

The same method serves the annual review and the renewal decision. An operator’s reporting is its own account of itself. An unannounced stay at the owner’s asset, with the estate tested beforehand, is the owner’s account.

Questions owners ask

  • What is a hotel management company?

    A firm that operates hotels for owners under management agreements, for fees, without owning the assets. Brands operate many hotels this way; independent management companies operate hotels under a brand’s franchise or unbranded.

  • How do owners choose a hotel management company in Europe?

    On fees, brand and distribution, track record, the proposed GM, and increasingly on evidence from the operator’s existing properties gathered as a guest.

  • What is the difference between a brand and a third-party operator?

    A brand operates under its own flag and standards; a third-party operator runs the hotel under a franchise or independently. Owners often combine a brand franchise with a third-party manager.

  • Can an Owner’s Audit be run at a prospective operator’s hotels?

    Yes. It is the most direct evidence available before signing: the operator’s delivery, unannounced, at assets like the owner’s.

  • Is a fee published?

    Fees follow scope, which depends on the properties, the season and whether comp set benchmarking is included. We agree it in conversation and are glad to give an early indication.

  • What are the top hotel management companies in Europe?

    The global brands (Accor, Marriott, Hilton, IHG, Hyatt) manage many hotels directly; independent operators such as Odyssey, NUMA, Meininger, and regional owner-operators such as Meliá, Barceló, RIU and Iberostar run their own and third-party assets. Which is best for an owner depends on the asset, and is best tested at the properties the operator already runs.

The Owner’s Audit

An in-residence hotel audit of the digital estate and the guest experience, commissioned by the owner rather than the operator. Unannounced, not silent. For luxury family resorts, golf resorts and five-star resorts in Europe.

Read how the Owner’s Audit runs

Engagements begin with a conversation: reachme@amirsani.com

Sources

  1. Bird & Bird, HMA Bites: Performance Tests
  2. Taylor Hospitality, What Owners Get Wrong When Evaluating Hotel Management Companies

Related